As a spine surgeon with over 25 years of experience, I have seen firsthand how challenging spinal fusion surgeries can be, both for patients and surgeons. The term spinal fusion failure refers to a situation where the intended goal of the surgery—fusion of the spine to create stability—does not occur.
Typically, a spinal fusion surgery is performed to stabilize the spine, reduce pain, or correct deformities. However, in some cases, the bones in the spine don’t fuse together as expected, leading to persistent pain and discomfort, also known as pseudoarthrosis.
This failure can leave patients frustrated, still dealing with the same pain they had before surgery, or even experiencing new issues. The good news is that spinal fusion failure is not as common as one might think, but it does happen in a small percentage of patients.
Around 10% to 40% of spinal fusion procedures may not achieve complete success. Factors like surgical technique, patient health, and even the number of spinal levels fused can influence the outcome.
But why does this happen? Let’s break down the primary causes of spinal fusion failure and how to identify if it’s affecting you.
When patients ask me why their spinal fusion surgery may have failed, there are typically a few common culprits. Smoking, for one, is a significant contributor.
Smoking affects the body’s ability to heal, especially in bone fusion. Nicotine interferes with bone formation, reducing bone mineral density and delaying healing, which increases the likelihood of fusion failure.
Another cause could be related to the bone graft used during surgery. A successful fusion depends on the bone graft material used to stimulate new bone growth between the vertebrae.
In my experience, autografts (bone taken from the patient’s own body) often yield the best results, but in cases where autografts aren’t possible, allografts or synthetic materials may be used. However, the choice of graft can sometimes affect the success of the fusion.
Surgical error, while rare, can also play a role. Performing the surgery at the wrong vertebral level or improper placement of the hardware can lead to failure.
Moreover, infections following surgery or inadequate preparation of the surgical site—such as failure to remove soft tissue properly—can hinder the fusion process. Finally, certain patient factors, such as obesity, age, or a history of multiple prior back surgeries, can increase the risk of spinal fusion failure.
Patients with complex spinal problems, like multi-level fusion surgeries, are also more prone to complications. As a surgeon, one of my main goals is to work closely with each patient to minimize these risks as much as possible.
Recognizing the signs of spinal fusion failure early on is crucial to addressing the issue before it worsens. The most common symptom is persistent back pain.
If the surgery was intended to relieve pain but you’re still experiencing significant discomfort, this could be an indication that the fusion has not occurred properly. Some patients describe the pain as similar to what they felt before the surgery, while others notice new, sharper pains in the lower back or around the surgical area.
Another symptom is radiating pain down the legs or arms, depending on which part of the spine was operated on. This occurs when there is pressure on the spinal nerves, a condition often associated with failed fusion or adjacent segment disease.
You might also experience tingling, numbness, or even weakness in your limbs—these are all signs that nerve-related issues could be at play. Sometimes, patients find they have less mobility after surgery.
If daily activities such as bending, lifting, or even sitting for extended periods become difficult or painful, it might indicate that the spinal fusion has not stabilized the spine properly. Infections, though less common, can also present with visible signs such as redness or swelling around the surgical incision, fever, or unusual drainage.
When these symptoms persist beyond the expected recovery time, or if they worsen, it’s important to seek medical advice immediately. Often, further diagnostic testing is required to pinpoint the exact cause of these ongoing issues.
If you’re experiencing ongoing symptoms following a spinal fusion surgery, the first thing you should do is contact your surgeon. A thorough evaluation is necessary to determine whether spinal fusion failure is the cause of your discomfort.
During this evaluation, we often perform imaging tests like MRI or CT scans to check if the bones have fused as intended. These tests can reveal whether there is pseudoarthrosis, improper hardware placement, or other complications like scar tissue or infection that might be causing your pain.
At Long Island Neuroscience Specialists, we emphasize the importance of a detailed follow-up with all patients. Sometimes, the symptoms might not be directly related to the fusion itself, but instead could be due to adjacent segment disease or nerve irritation.
Regardless, an accurate diagnosis is essential for determining the best course of action. In some cases, patients find it helpful to seek a second opinion.
While our team has over 25 years of expertise in spine surgery, we understand that patients may feel anxious about their symptoms, and a second opinion can offer peace of mind or new insights into their condition.
When treating spinal fusion failure, there are several paths we can take, depending on the severity of the problem and the patient’s overall health. One common option is revision surgery.
During a revision, we may use more advanced hardware or adjust the existing hardware to better support the spine. In some cases, we may also perform additional bone grafting to improve the chances of a successful fusion.
However, surgery is not always necessary. For patients dealing with chronic pain but no major structural issues, non-surgical treatments can be effective.
This may include physical therapy to strengthen the muscles around the spine, improve mobility, and reduce pain. Physical therapists work closely with us to design individualized rehabilitation programs that focus on rebuilding strength and flexibility.
Another treatment option that has proven effective for some patients is spinal cord stimulation (SCS). This involves placing a small device near the spinal cord that sends electrical pulses to block pain signals from reaching the brain.
While SCS doesn’t correct the fusion itself, it can offer significant pain relief for patients who are not candidates for further surgery. Medications such as NSAIDs or gabapentinoids (used for nerve pain) can also be used to manage symptoms.
In my practice, I emphasize a multi-disciplinary approach, where pain management specialists, physical therapists, and spine surgeons all collaborate to provide the best care possible. Read more here.
For many patients, non-surgical treatments offer relief from pain after a failed spinal fusion. Physical therapy is one of the most important tools in this process.
By focusing on core strengthening, posture correction, and flexibility, patients can alleviate stress on their spine and reduce pain. Over time, consistent physical therapy can improve overall function and prevent further complications.
Another important component of non-surgical management is cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). Often, chronic pain is not just a physical issue but also a psychological one.
CBT helps patients develop coping mechanisms for pain, which can improve their mental health and reduce the perception of pain. In my experience, patients who engage in both physical and psychological therapies tend to see better long-term outcomes.
Medications also play a key role in non-surgical management. For example, non-opioid pain relievers like NSAIDs can help control inflammation, while muscle relaxants or nerve pain medications such as gabapentinoids can address specific pain triggers.
Additionally, lifestyle modifications such as weight management, quitting smoking, and proper posture can significantly impact the long-term success of non-surgical interventions. Finally, enrolling in a specialized pain management program can be beneficial.
These programs often offer a combination of physical therapy, pain relief injections, and psychological support, all aimed at managing chronic pain without the need for additional surgery. Read more here.
Preventing spinal fusion failure starts well before the surgery itself. As a surgeon, I always stress the importance of preoperative preparation.
Patients who are in better health prior to surgery—whether it’s through losing excess weight, quitting smoking, or managing chronic conditions like diabetes—tend to have better outcomes. Once the surgery is complete, following post-operative instructions is crucial.
This means avoiding heavy lifting or strenuous activities that could compromise the healing process. Patients should also attend all follow-up appointments, where we monitor their progress with imaging and physical exams to ensure the bones are fusing as expected.
Choosing the right bone graft material during surgery is another key factor. As mentioned earlier, autografts tend to have the best success rates, but in some cases, allografts or synthetic materials may be used.
Regardless, proper placement and compression of the graft are essential to ensure solid fusion. Additionally, using spinal hardware like rods or screws to support the fusion site can improve outcomes.
However, even with proper hardware placement, it’s important to keep an eye on potential complications, such as implant loosening or breakage, which could lead to future problems. Finally, maintaining a healthy lifestyle post-surgery can significantly reduce the risk of fusion failure.
Eating a balanced diet rich in calcium and vitamin D, staying active with low-impact exercises, and avoiding smoking are all vital to promoting bone health and ensuring the fusion is successful.
While non-surgical options work well for many, some patients require revision surgery to correct a failed fusion. In revision surgery, we address the underlying issues that caused the original surgery to fail.
In revision surgery, we focus on correcting the structural problems that caused the initial spinal fusion to fail. This might involve adding new bone graft material, adjusting or replacing spinal hardware, or even addressing adjacent segment disease if nearby spinal segments have degenerated due to increased stress from the original fusion.
Revision surgeries tend to be more complex than the initial procedure, and the success rates vary based on a number of factors. These include the patient’s overall health, the number of levels fused, and the reason for the original failure.
In some cases, the surgery may focus on reducing pain and improving function rather than achieving a full correction of the failed fusion. It’s important to have realistic expectations going into revision surgery.
While many patients experience significant relief, others may continue to experience some level of discomfort. That’s why it’s crucial to engage in a thorough discussion with your surgeon about the risks and benefits before moving forward.
For some patients, revision surgery may not be the best option. In these cases, managing symptoms through non-surgical treatments, such as physical therapy or pain management techniques like spinal cord stimulation, can offer a more viable long-term solution.
While revision surgery or non-surgical treatments can help manage symptoms, it’s important to understand the long-term risks and complications associated with spinal fusion failure. One of the most common complications is chronic pain.
Even with revision surgery, some patients may continue to experience back or leg pain due to nerve damage, scar tissue formation, or unresolved spinal instability. Another complication to watch for is adjacent segment disease (ASD).
This occurs when the spinal segments above or below the fusion site start to degenerate because they are now bearing additional stress. ASD can cause new pain and may require additional treatment, including further surgery.
Implant-related complications are another potential issue. Over time, spinal hardware such as rods and screws can loosen, break, or shift, which can cause discomfort and require surgical intervention.
This is especially true in cases where the fusion has not fully set, and the hardware is taking on more stress than it was designed to handle. Nerve damage is also a concern, particularly if the original fusion or a revision surgery involves manipulation of the nerves.
Permanent nerve damage can lead to lasting symptoms like tingling, numbness, or weakness in the legs or arms, depending on the location of the fusion. Lastly, the emotional and psychological toll of spinal fusion failure should not be underestimated.
Many patients struggle with feelings of frustration or depression when their surgery doesn’t provide the relief they were hoping for. It’s crucial to address both the physical and emotional aspects of recovery, as mental health plays a significant role in overall well-being and pain perception.
Ensuring a successful spinal fusion surgery—or addressing a spinal fusion failure—requires close collaboration between the patient and their healthcare team. At Long Island Neuroscience Specialists, we prioritize open communication with our patients throughout the entire process, from preoperative planning to post-surgery recovery.
One of the key components of a successful surgery is setting realistic expectations. Not every patient will experience complete pain relief after spinal fusion, especially if the underlying condition was complex.
By having clear, open discussions about the potential outcomes and recovery process, we help patients feel more informed and prepared for what lies ahead. Regular follow-up appointments are also essential to monitor the progress of the fusion.
During these visits, we may use imaging tests such as X-rays, MRIs, or CT scans to check the status of the fusion and ensure that the bones are healing properly. If any issues arise, such as signs of hardware failure or adjacent segment disease, early intervention can help prevent further complications.
Patient education is another critical factor in ensuring long-term success. We work closely with our patients to provide detailed instructions on post-surgery care, including activity restrictions, physical therapy exercises, and lifestyle changes that can support recovery.
By empowering patients with the knowledge they need, we help them take an active role in their own healing process. Finally, having an interdisciplinary team that includes surgeons, physical therapists, pain management specialists, and mental health professionals ensures that all aspects of a patient’s recovery are addressed.
This comprehensive approach improves overall outcomes and helps patients achieve a better quality of life after spinal fusion surgery.
Spinal fusion failure can be a challenging and frustrating experience, but with the right approach, there are many options for managing symptoms and improving quality of life. From revision surgery to non-surgical treatments like physical therapy and pain management, there are solutions available to address the ongoing issues that may arise from a failed fusion.
At Long Island Neuroscience Specialists, we bring over 25 years of expertise in spine surgery to ensure that our patients receive the best possible care. Whether you’re considering a spinal fusion surgery for the first time or seeking treatment for a failed fusion, we are here to guide you every step of the way.
Through personalized care, advanced surgical techniques, and a multidisciplinary approach, we help our patients achieve the best possible outcomes. If you suspect that your spinal fusion surgery has not been successful, don’t hesitate to reach out to us.
Early intervention and a comprehensive treatment plan can make all the difference in your recovery and long-term well-being. Together, we can work toward finding a solution that helps you get back to living a pain-free, active life.
GET IN TOUCH +
285 Sills Road
Building 5-6, Suite E
East Patchogue, NY 11772
(631) 475-5511
184 N. Belle Mead Road
East Setauket, NY 11733
(631) 675-6226
GET IN TOUCH +
285 Sills Road
Building 5-6, Suite E
East Patchogue, NY 11772
(631) 475-5511
184 N. Belle Mead Road
East Setauket, NY 11733
(631) 675-6226
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER +
Send us a Google review. Click this link and let us know how we did!
Review us on Yelp too.
© 2022 - 2023 Long Island Neuroscience Specialists. All Rights Reserved
Designed & Developed by Vibe Branding
Designed & Developed by Vibe Branding
